Saturday, July 20, 2013

UTTARAKHAND TRAGEDY; Development Needed But Not at Cost of Human Lives

The heavy downpour in Uttarakhand and the aftermath, which usurped hundreds of lives and left thousands stranded, is one of the worst natural calamities. The death toll, as we rush to the Press, is reported officially to be around 680 but it might climb to thousands when you will be reading the article. Around 10,000 personnel of Armed Forces on war footing for six days with 46 choppers including the advanced Mi-16, Mi-17, Mi-26 and the newly acquired C-130J Super Hercules are yet to approach nearly 50,000 people stranded in different parts of the 40,000 km inundated area.
The flood has once again exposed the preparedness of the country for natural disasters. The Chief Minister of Uttarakhand, Vijaya Bahuguna, in an interview with CNN, rightly confessed that the state disaster management committee did not meet in last six years and that the team was not prepared at all to handle the situation. The CM went on saying, “The government of India and those who are writing stories also have no force to deal with disasters like this.”

THE CALAMITY
The dual cloud burst and subsequent crumbling of Kedar Dome on 18 June caused a major rupture in the Charbari Lake which is at the distance of just 5 KMs from the Kedar Nath temple. The locality registered a record rainfall of 340 mm in the locality that day while, usually, the rainfall more than 150 mm a day is termed a heavy one in climatology.
This hazardous downpour made many believe that it was a man-made disaster and was nature’s way to avenge its exploitation. They have some points too. If you go through the map of flood hit areas, you will find it fully covered with sky touching mountains and the vegetative cover on mountains, which are comparably less on these ones, slows down the speed of rain before touching the ground or rather soak it midway. Also the global warming has affected the ecosystems of Himalaya most adversely in 100 years. Hence, the glaciers naturally release higher water in Himalayan rivers.
Unregulated expansion of giant hydro-electric projects and the incessant construction of roads in the area have also played their role in making mountains feeble hence causing landslides. Some say it was the failure of Bahuguna’s government which amplified the adversity. On the other hand, the Union Home Minister, Shushil Kumar Shinde, brushed aside these allegations saying it was natural.

THE PREVENTION
Whatever the reason for this calamity may be, the fact is that all are busy passing the ball in their rival’s court and considering themselves not responsible. Ironically, what if the global warming is responsible for this disaster? The crisis started centuries ago. Can anyone claim that the world has ever taken a single step since then to reduce the same or not our each move amounting to its magnitude? Similar talks had been made after the Nargis, the Hurricane Sandy, the Neelam and other such disasters. These topics are only to be talked about. What was and still is in our hand to minimise the wreckage is to put bridle on our so-called development model ignoring norms and the standards of the eco system.
The former Deputy Director-General of the Geological Survey of India, VK Raina, said in a statement that the natural calamities such as cloud bursts, flash floods et al cannot be prevented but deaths and damages could be contained by implementing the laws appropriately. Pertaining to note here is that the Ministry of Environment and Forests, on 18 December 2012, issued a notification declaring the entire watershed between Gaumukh and Uttarkashi, along the Bhagirathi river as eco-sensitive zone and banned all construction activities in the area at the stretch of 135 KMs. But the state government had opposed this move strongly saying this will hamper the development and economic growth in the area.
In the name of urbanisation and development, the locality is registering an increase in its population on a regular basis ignoring the environmental threats. Who guarantee that the same would not happen when the area has been converted into a city with millions of residents? We undoubtedly need development but not at the cost of our precious lives. Or ultimately one can say the Indians sacrifice their lives generously even for some petty causes like cold waves, heat waves, bushfires, road accidents et al then why this hullabaloo if the same is done for a relatively greater cause?

THE RELIEF WORK
No relief work is taking place in the area in an organised way. What the Armed Forces are doing is to rescue or airlift stranded people and help them reach relatively safer places. The situation at Jolly Grant Airport, Sahasradhara helipad and at local hospitals is far beyond to be confined in words. The rescued people, after having spent two or three days without any food and grain, are forced to expend up to Rs 200 for a biscuit pack worth Rs. 5. Some have bought a petty water bottle against Rs. 100. Nutan Shukla of Bareilly paid Rs. 5000 for one time meal for a group of five persons. The helicopter companies also charge per hour for the operation.
Since the relief work is not carried out in an organised way, it is hard to say who is doing what in this regard. But, a group of locals has been seen active at Jolly Grant Airport and nearby areas with eatables and so. Also the Shiromani Gurdawara Prabandhak Committee has set up a Langar (mass distribution of foods) outside Jolly Grant Airport. On being asked, a national secretary of Jamaat-e-Islami Hind, wishing anonymity, said that the state unit has to take initiative and the Markaz (centre) is in touch with them. Hopefully, the operation would start soon. Mualana Abdul Hameed Nomani, General Secretary of Jamiatul Ulema Hind, while talking to the Radiance said the state unit of JUH is doing “something” but he did not explain what this “something” is.
Likewise, the All India Shi’a Personal Law Board has set up a relief fund for the victims and Maulana Firangimahli of All India Muslim Personal Law Board has urged every individual to participate actively in rescue and relief operation. To the social organisations and other NGOs, what this scribe wishes to say is that leave the rescue at Armed Forces as only they can do it in a better way but do make yourselves available for the rehabilitation of those rescued.

 Also available on

No comments:

Post a Comment